But Then What ?
By Sam Jarman –
The recent emphasis on and awareness of mental health in sport and in society is welcome.
However, there seems to be confusion around what constitutes ‘mental health’, and ‘mental illness’.
Where does well-being come from and how can we find it again when it has apparently been lost?
This confusion is absolutely not the fault of anyone who is suffering with their feelings and emotions.
The authorities we look to for guidance – academia, public health and sports organisations – appear to be in a similar state of conflict.
There are varying definitions, categorisations and approaches to dealing with what is undoubtedly a serious and growing problem.
This article is an attempt to help coaches and players to understand the conversation around this important topic.
Where should we start if and when the people around us are struggling?
The ‘Medicalisation’ of Mental Health
Increasingly in discussions about well-being, the words ‘mind’ and ‘brain’ are used synonymously.
The terms ‘mental health’ and ‘mental illness’ imply a pathological aspect to our thoughts, feelings perceptions etc.
Psychiatry, behaviouralist psychology and psychotherapy have at their roots the assumption that thoughts and feelings, and therefore any maladies associated with them, originate in the brain.
Theories being advanced by neuroscience link brain activity to subjective experience. These concepts are tempting for coaches or sports psychologists when faced with an athlete or a team who is struggling.
They perpetuate the belief that low moods, lack of motivation or confidence are physical or biological issues.
It’s undeniable that a small number of human beings have brains which are malfunctioning in some way, either due to genetics, physical injury such as concussion, or through substance misuse; drugs, alcohol etc.
In these cases, a medical intervention may well be the most appropriate point of call.
However, the vast majority of people who are suffering with their thoughts, feelings and emotions are otherwise perfectly healthy.
Physiological, or Philosophical?
Not enjoying your sport as much as you used to?
Feeling anxious about the outcome of a game?
Suffering from a lack of confidence?
Worrying about your relationships with team-mates or coaching staff?
These aren’t physical, medical or biological problems.
They are spiritual.
They stem from a misunderstanding of human nature, of the way the world really is, about who you are and about the meaning of life and sport.
Unfortunately, the common response from the mental health professions to these misunderstandings is a prescription.
The assumption that ‘mind’ is an emergent property of the brain. That it exists separately within an individual is what leads to the labelling of millions of intelligent, creative, energetic, curious children as having a medical ‘disorder’ (ADHD).
They are routinely given drugs to alter their brain chemistry.
A good thing for the pharmaceutical industry.
Not so good for children and their parents.
What About Psychology?
In between medicine and philosophy sits psychology.
Psychology is mainly a process of analysing, categorising and processing emotions and behaviours.
Exploring what might have happened in your past to make you feel the way you feel might be helpful in the short term.
But the problems in your life are still going to be there.
You can’t change the past. And delving into previous events doesn’t necessarily help with the present or the future.
Understanding yourself is not about memorising the ‘Encyclopaedia of You’.
Will investigating, analysing and categorising every detail of your past and present add to the baggage you are carrying around with you?
Or will it lighten the load?
It’s normal to have problems, feelings and emotions.
Distress is not a disease.
Similar Questions, Different Answers
Philosophers and psychologists are asking many of the same questions. The difference comes in the methodology of study and the interpretation of the answers.
Psychology tries to solve emotional problems using the methodology of science.
Experiments are carried out, data is compiled. Statistics are assembled and conclusions are drawn. Reliable statistics can be useful when we are looking at large groups of people.
But they tell you very little about an individual.
Studies suggest that achieving a goal you have worked your whole life towards should make you feel happy, fulfilled and at peace.
But this isn’t much comfort when the day after winning a major tournament or match, you feel empty and life seems to have lost some of its meaning.
Philosophy addresses the same questions as psychology, but through dialogue, logic, reason and insight.
In an ideal world the two approaches would work hand in hand. A combination of both should lead to the most satisfactory outcomes.
Observation, perception, experimentation and analysis of experience are more commonly associated with psychology.
But when it comes to the subjective matters of thoughts and feelings, the data can only be interpreted from a philosophical and spiritual standpoint.
Keep It Simple
So, where should we start in attempting to assist athletes and coaches who are feeling low or under pressure and are wondering where to turn?
Occam’s Razor is a philosophical principle which states that if there are several possible answers, the simplest explanation for an unexplained phenomenon is the most likely.
If you are walking in the English countryside and you hear hoof beats, think horses, not zebras.
Research and experience tell us that the likelihood of a previously healthy, relatively happy person suddenly developing a physical issue with their brain causing them to feel depressed, is very low.
So, logic would suggest that something else is responsible for the change in your mood.
For example, if you believe your innate well-being and value as a person can be impacted by how your team is playing or whether your contract is going to be renewed, you may well feel anxious or insecure.
If you believe that you need to feel a certain way or have a certain state of mind in order to perform or enjoy your sport, you might experience frustration or powerlessness when that feeling or mindset proves elusive.
The question is this: Are your emotions more likely due to a malfunction in your understanding about who you are and how life works.
Or to a malfunction in your brain chemistry?
Could a misunderstanding about yourself, your worldview or a misplaced belief about your life or sport have obscured your natural, innate well-being?
Could this be causing you to feel anxious insecure, frustrated or de-motivated?
If you suspect that might be the case, a medical or pharmaceutical intervention seems inappropriate.
It’s Good to Talk
Most people can assess and define a ‘problem’ in the material world that seems to have precipitated their feelings. If you feel that you have got to this point, the next step is almost always to talk to someone about it.
Simple dialogue with another caring individual is at the heart of all therapeutic relationships.
There is considerable debate as to whether any healing that does take place is a result of the connection between the two people, more so than something that was said or any technique that may have been employed.
Just getting your worries off your chest can often be enough to get some space between you and the issue.
Often insights will take the opportunity to jump into the space and move you forwards.
Sometimes the counsellor or mentor can offer a different perspective on things. Again this might allow an insight to arise.
The question of who to turn to is what prevents many athletes and coaches from seeking support. This can become another worry in itself.
Opening up to someone else within your sporting organisation can be an uncomfortable proposition. Concerns about appearing ‘mentally weak’ to peers or people above you in the hierarchy can make this a big step to take.
Family or close friends can be an option. But the same worries may arise, along with the feeling that they might not really understand the situation or be able to offer practical advice.
Many athletes and coaches pride themselves on their self-sufficiency. They don’t want to burden those closest to them with their problems and issues.
Approaching a mental health professional is an option, but many are reluctant to do so due to the ‘medicalisation’ problem outlined above.
Finding a neutral third party who you can trust. Someone who you feel will listen carefully, can understand your situation and who isn’t going to jump to a conclusion, to judge you or try to fix you can often be a game changer for an athlete who is struggling.
A Philosophy for Sport and Life
Not feeling good about your sport or your life is much more likely to be a disorder in your concepts about how the world works, than a disorder in the way your brain is functioning.
Someone who can help you investigate those concepts and help you make sense of them is likely to be more helpful than a prescription or delving into memories of your childhood or past sporting experiences.
Everyone suffers from low moods and ill feelings from time to time.
Understanding yourself, your values and your beliefs and integrating them into a coherent, functional and enjoyable approach to sport and life is the best way we have found to ride them out and learn from the experience.
Doing so can often lead to a resurgence in motivation and confidence and the recollection of why you fell in love with your sport in the first place.
If you would like to learn more or to explore this idea further, please get in touch.
Join the Sports Principles Community!
Please leave your name and email address below to get the latest news and updates.